Connect with us

Headlines

Nigeria Loses Sovereign Immunity Claim As US Court Upholds $70m Award to Chinese Firm

Published

on

Nigeria’s claim to sovereign immunity cannot stand in a commercial venture, a US Appeal Court has ruled.

The court rejected Nigeria’s sovereign immunity defence to the enforcement of a $70 million investment treaty award won by Zhongshan Fucheng Industrial Investment Co. Ltd., a Chinese investor, in a free trade zone.

Nigeria had “gruesomely” violated both fundamental and commercial rights of the Chinese firm, judges at the US Court of Appeals in Washington DC ruled.

In a 2-1 verdict delivered on August 9, documents of which are attached, majority ruling affirmed the judgment of the US district court for the District of Columbia that held that the arbitration award is enforceable.

In January 2023, Beryl Howell, the presiding judge of the lower court, dismissed Nigeria’s argument that the court did not have jurisdiction over the case since the country is a sovereign entity.

Howell held that the court has jurisdiction since the United Kingdom (UK), where the $70 million arbitration award was issued against Nigeria, is a signatory to the New York Convention.

In 2010, Zhongshan, through Zhuhai Zhongfu Industrial Group Co. Ltd. (Zhuhai), its Chinese parent company, acquired rights to develop a free trade zone in Ogun state.

A year later, Zhongshan set up Zhongfu International Investment (NIG) FZE (Zhongfu), a Nigerian entity, to manage the project under the permission of the Ogun state government.

However, things took a different turn in July 2016 when the investor accused the state government of abruptly moving to terminate its appointment while attempting to install a new manager for the free trade zone.

Subsequently, Zhongfu initiated an investment treaty arbitration against Nigeria under the bilateral investment treaty between the People’s Republic of China and Nigeria (the China-Nigeria BIT).

The arbitrators had ruled that Nigeria was in breach of its obligations under the China-Nigeria BIT and awarded Zhongshan compensation of around $70 million.

In January 2022, the Chinese company initiated a case to seek enforcement of the arbitration award.

Nigeria pleaded state immunity but was turned away by Sara Cockerill, a high court judge in the UK, who said the country abused the time frame for appealing arbitral awards.

In the majority judgment, the US appellant court held that the final arbitration award is enforceable under the New York convention since the dispute is between “persons” that share a legal commercial relationship.

The court ruled that the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA) arbitration exception stripped Nigeria of the sovereign immunity in the arbitration award case.

“For the foregoing reasons, we hold that the final award is enforceable under the New York convention because it arose out of differences between ‘persons’ that share a legal, commercial relationship,” the majority judgment reads.

“The district court therefore has jurisdiction over this case under the FSIA’s arbitration exception. The judgment of the district court is affirmed.”

The majority judgment was issued by Patricia Millett and Julianna Childs.

In the dissenting judgment, Gregory Katsas, the third judge, argued that when the New York convention was drafted, the word “persons” did not include a sovereign nation.

Katsas held that the action of Ogun State cannot be attributed to Nigeria, adding that the arbitration award “arises solely out of Nigeria’s sovereign acts governed by public international law”.

“Text, legal context, and drafting history all indicate that the word ‘persons,’ as used in the New York Convention, does not include signatory nations acting as sovereigns. I respectfully dissent,” Katsas said.

Three days after the judgment of the US appeal court, a Paris court in France ordered the seizure of three jets belonging to the Nigerian government over the dispute involving the arbitration award to the Chinese firms.

In 2023, a court of appeal in the UK ruled that Nigeria is liable for a $70 million arbitration award in favour of the Chinese firm.

The development means that Nigeria has lost arbitration award cases against the Chinese firm in France, the US, and the UK.

The Nigerian government has accused the Chinese firm of attempting to use deceptive means to acquire the country’s offshore assets.

Agency Report

Below is the detailed judgment:

23-7016-2069169

United States Court of Appeals

Continue Reading
Advertisement


Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Headlines

Sarr Focused on Palace Return after Liverpool Interest

Published

on

Crystal Palace forward Ismaila Sarr says he has moved on from Liverpool‘s interest in signing him and is keen for a “fresh start” under new manager Thomas Frank.

The Senegal international, 28, is keen to put that episode behind him after Liverpool explored a move at the end of the summer transfer window.

Ultimately, Palace rejected advances for Sarr, who scored 21 goals in 45 games in all competitions last season as his side won the Conference League, while Liverpool opted to keep Cody Gakpo despite interest from Manchester City.

In his first interview since Liverpool’s pursuit of him, Sarr – who has been nominated for the African footballer of the year award – told BBC Sport: “Liverpool is one of the biggest clubs in world football and, when a club like that shows an interest in you, of course it’s something you take seriously.

“I don’t think any player would be indifferent to that kind of opportunity. It was an interesting possibility, and naturally, I considered what it could mean for my career.

“Today, that chapter is behind me. I’ve always believed that you can’t move forward if you’re constantly looking in the rear-view mirror.

“I’m a Crystal Palace player, I’m proud of what we’ve achieved together, and my focus is on getting back on the pitch and helping the team.”

Sarr is still sidelined with a groin injury, but talks are ongoing with Palace over an improved contract – despite his current deal running until 2029.

He added: “Yes, there have been discussions with the club. For now, I prefer to let those conversations happen privately and concentrate on football.”

Sarr missed most of Pierre Sage’s spell in charge, making just two brief substitute appearances in the Premier League this season.

Sage was replaced by former Tottenham Hotspur and Brentford manager Frank this week.

“Of course, it’s a difficult moment for everyone at the club,” Sarr said. “After everything we achieved last season, nobody expected us to be in this position.

“But I know the quality of this squad. We have very good players, a strong group and the ability to turn things around.

“The arrival of Thomas Frank is an opportunity for a fresh start, new energy and a different approach. We all have to take responsibility, work together and fight for every point.

“I’m confident we can overcome this difficult period and achieve our objectives this season.”

Sarr hopes award goes to Senegalese player

Sarr is on 10-man shortlist for the African Player of the Year award, which will be presented on 7 December in Lagos, Nigeria.

It follows Sarr being named Conference League Player of the Season, scoring nine goals as Palace won their first European title. He also collected both the club’s player of the year and players’ player of the year awards.

Sarr went on to score four goals for Senegal at the 2026 World Cup, after featuring in a controversial Africa Cup of Nations final in January.

In March, Senegal’s final victory over Morocco was overturned after players left the pitch without the authorisation of the referee.

As Senegal appeal to be reawarded with their title at the Court of Arbitration for Sport (Cas), Sarr remains proud that his side “became the African champions on the pitch”.

Asked about his chances of winning the African Player of the Year award, he said: “I’m proud of the season I’ve had, both with Crystal Palace and Senegal. It’s been a special year, with important trophies and individual achievements.

“But African football has so many outstanding players, and several of them have also had fantastic seasons.

“I’m thinking particularly of my Senegalese brothers Sadio Mane and Pape Gueye, who also deserve recognition for what they’ve achieved.

“Of course, winning the award would be an incredible honour. Every African player dreams of that.

“But honestly, what matters most to me is seeing the trophy go to Senegal. I’m incredibly proud of what we accomplished together.”

Source: bbc.com

Continue Reading

Headlines

Former Green Eagles Captain, Segun Odegbami Escapes Assassination at Abeokuta Residence

Published

on

A former Nigerian international footballer, Chief Segun Odegbami, was on Friday morning attacked and macheted by unknown assailants at his Abeokuta residence.

Odegbami, a sports administrator and owner of Eagles 7 Sports Radio 103.7FM, according to reports, was attacked in the early hours of the day, inside his Ibara GRA residence.

He sustained injuries as a result of the attack.

Reports further said that the attackers, numbering about three, after gaining entry into the premises, descended heavily on Odegbami’s domestic staff and driver before accessing his bedroom.

The septuagenarian, it was further gathered, challenged the assistants, which resulted in a serious scuffle and they escaped after inflicting deep machete cuts on their target.

“The incident is unfortunate. We heard that the armed men struck in the early hours of today (Friday) and first overpowered the domestic staff. They asked for Chief Segun Odegbami and his staff denied that he was at home.

“But the generator was on at that time. So, the armed men believed he must be at home and they handed severe beatings to the staff. They immediately found their way to Odegbami’s bedroom and attacked him there.

“Not willing to succumb easily, Odegbami also resisted his attackers, who quickly fled the scene and left him bleeding heavily,” reports quoting a source said.

The ex-international was rushed to an undisclosed hospital where he is currently receiving treatment.

Some residents of the community confirmed that the matter was promptly reported to the police.

However, the State Police Public Relations Officer, DSP Oluseyi Babaseyi, could not be reached for comments as of the time of filing this report.

Continue Reading

Headlines

2027: Some Govs Praying for Tinubu’s Defeat – Dele Momodu

Published

on

A chieftain of the African Democratic Congress (ADC), Dele Momodu, has said that some Nigerian governors are secretly praying for divine intervention to stop President Bola Tinubu from securing a second term in office.

Momodu alleged that governors across the country had become afraid of Tinubu, whom he accused of concentrating power and intimidating political leaders.

He made the allegation on Thursday while speaking as a guest on Channels Television’s Politics Today programme.

The ADC chieftain expressed concern over what he described as the growing threat to Nigeria’s democracy, claiming that the president has taken control of key institutions of government.

According to him, the judiciary, legislature and even members of the executive arm of government are afraid of the President.

Momodu said he has several friends among the governors and knows that many of them are uncomfortable with the current political situation.

“The governors are scared. I have a lot of friends who are governors. They are scared of one man because they believe he’s so ruthless, and he has always bullied his way anyway in whatever he did growing up.

“So they believe he’s using the same, you know, mafia tactic of saying yes, I’m in charge.”

“The judiciary is afraid. The legislature is afraid. The executive is afraid,” he said.

He further claimed that governors are no longer exercising the influence and authority associated with their offices, alleging that they were being treated like domestic servants.

“Nigerians, I can tell you, even governors are praying fervently and quietly that God should please remove this pestilence for them, because for the first time, governors have lost their power.

“They’ve lost their integrity. People used to see governors as mini presidents. Governors are now being treated like houseboys, which is very ugly,” Momodu added.

He warned that the alleged concentration of power in the hands of the President is unhealthy for Nigeria’s democracy.

Continue Reading